Stereotypes with Chinese Characteristics

One classroom lecture that I’ve repeatedly used and refined during my time in China has been an exploration of student understandings of stereotypes and the propagation of stereotypes among the Chinese urban middle class. What stands out during the lesson is the degree to which some kinds of imagery — the Arab terrorist, the black athlete — have become so globalized that many Chinese sound exactly like their American counterparts when discussing people from different backgrounds.

I generally begin this lesson by defining the word stereotype and inviting students to offer stereotypes, positive and negative, of men and women. This makes things lively at the start, especially in classes with a strong mix of male and female students. From there we move on to stereotypes of people from different parts of China.

I asked the students to complete sentences such as the following:

  • Dongbei people are …
  • Beijing people are …
  • Hong Kong people are …
  • Xinjiang people are …

Not surprisingly, Dongbei people — in Tianjin at least — were painted in colorful but positive terms, but people in the capital were ripped on heavily, while those from Xinjiang came in for the most negative stereotypes (“monstrous,” “dangerous,” “terrorists”). This impression of Uighur people is worrying to me since, of all of China’s minority groups today, they have the greatest chance to face discrimination in society, and when stories like this one go flickering into the public consciousness, the stereotyping verges on becoming a permanent fixture in Chinese thought.

Returning to the lecture, one thing I added tonight was a group quasi-experiment in which the students were shown a series of photos and asked for their impressions. Since our reactions to the appearance of strangers can be influenced by the stereotypes we subscribe to, this was another way to gauge the prevalence of certain stereotypes among my students. That said, this wasn’t a truly scientific survey,* and I “rigged” things a bit when choosing the nine images shown in the collage below by making sure some photos were out-of-character for the person depicted:

stereotypes collage

These images are all famous people save one (the Sikh in the center left), and except perhaps for young Michael Jackson (top center), none of them are recognizable to most Chinese. What reactions did the students have?

  • Ted Bundy (top left): “intelligent,” “businessman,” “lawyer”
  • Michael Jackson (top center): “poor,” “good at sports”
  • Gov. Bobby Jindal and family (top right): “happy,” “Middle Eastern,” “not American”
  • Sikh man (center left): “Bin Laden,” “Arab,” “oil merchant,” “terrorist”
  • Kristen Kreuk (center): “model,” “actress,” “mixed”
  • Kim Jong-nam (center right): “rich,” “countryside person,” “taxi driver”
  • Augusto Pinochet (bottom left): “Nazi,” “strong man,” “Japanese”
  • Cindy McCain (bottom center): “businesswoman,” “serious,” “kind”
  • Bobby Bowden (bottom right): “government official,” “intelligent,” “European”

To analyze the responses a bit, I created this segment of the lecture expecting the Sikh to catch most of the negative comments, since Westerners also mistake Sikhs for Muslim fundamentalist Arabs and thereby transfer negative stereotypes from Arabs to Sikhs. Furthermore, I deliberately included a friendly-looking Ted Bundy, so as to further underscore the point of the dangers of stereotyping, and the students fell for my “trap.” The other results are across the board, and the reactions to Bobby Bowden and Kim Jong-nam made me laugh. Lastly, while liberals may be heartened by my students’ reaction to Pinochet, China throws a wrinkle into the mix because being Nazi-like is not always negative here.

But that’s a subject for another post.

* A scientific survey would probably involve individual testing and ask respondents to simply note whether they had good feelings or bad feelings about the person they were looking at.


5 thoughts on “Stereotypes with Chinese Characteristics

  1. Interesting experiment. I would like to, with your permission of course, print off those photos and try it in my own classes. Of course, I’d have to figure out how to work this into Academic Writing….

    If I were to do this, though, I’d have to replace the photos of Kristen Kreuk, Cindy McCain and Bobby Bowden with people I’ve actually heard of.

    Unfortunately, your Sikh does look rather Muslim with his scraggly, unrolled beard. I would’ve said Pakistani or Afghan, though.

    And what interested me about the picture of Pinochet was the response “Japanese”. To be expected, I guess. It is worrying, though, that the only response that can be considered wholly negative (in the modern Chinese urban youth context, of course) was Japanese. “Nazi” and “strongman” could be seen as representing some people’s desires for their own country. Or is my imagination getting a bit too carried away here?

  2. Sure Chris, I’ll send you the pictures.

    I see what you’re saying about the Sikh, but again I was trying to trick the students’ perceptions. I didn’t go into how some Americans attacked Sikhs post-911, assuming them to be Muslims, but that’d be a good extension of that point.

    There’s another famous shot of Pinochet sitting with his arms crossed and with his sunglasses on, and I showed that to my girlfriend and she also said, “Japanese?”

  3. As someone who used to have a pretty major crush on Kristin Kreuk in college (making Smallville almost tolerable to watch) I’m surprised your students didn’t say, “beautiful”, “hot”, “sexy”. 🙂

    Great post- and I too have experienced somewhat revolting Chinese essays about Hitler and Stalin and other strongmen who have an odd appeal to the sexually frustrated seventeen-year-old boys I used to teach.

    The best was Ted Bundy- I didn’t recognize him and would have said the same things that your students did. And I find it fantastic and hilarious that Bobby Bowden- the consummate American college football coach- could be described as “European”.

    Chris- Cindy McCain is John McCain’s wife and the would-be First Lady should McCain win the election this fall.

  4. Actually Matt, they did call Kreuk gorgeous and whatnot, I’m just posting their reactions about who she is, not how she looks. They also thought Bundy was handsome and Michael Jackson was cute.

  5. Matt Schiavenza- that would’ve been my assumption, but I prefer to avoid assumptions, they can lead to trouble. But thanks for confirming that.

    And I have no idea what the consummate American college football coach is, but I could see that Bobby Bowden guy on the sidelines of a Bundesliga match.

Comments are closed.